This past January I signed up for the Sketchbook Skool six week “kourse” called Expressing as part of my goal for this year to focus more on my personal sketchbooks. This is my honest review of the program for the benefit of anyone else who may be considering enrolling.
The main reason why I signed up was because Michael Nobbs and Penelope Dullaghan were being featured as instructors, and I am a long time follower of both for many years. Also, I enrolled with a 20% off promo code which made the normally $99 cost a bit easier to swallow.
The kourse was broken up into six, one week long lessons featuring a different artist each week. Each weekly lesson consisted of a series of short (10 minutes or less) videos (introductory, biographical, sketchbook tours, and demos). Most of the videos had question prompts meant to spur discussion in the forums. There was also a weekly homework assignment with instructions to post in the forums for the other participants to view and/or comment. Some of the topics in the kourse included traditional watercolor techniques (such as glazes and washes), hand lettering, handmade books (mostly how to do the design and layout of the content, NOT bookbinding itself), sketching digitally on a tablet, and some very cool printmaking techniques. These are some of my impressions on Expressing:
- The videos were professionally produced with music, bright lighting, and nice zoom in shots so you can see clearly.
- The website is attractively designed with black text on bright white backgrounds and lots of pops of bright colors.
- New lessons were posted each Friday, which is ideal for someone who works M-F and wants to spend time on the weekends viewing the new content.
- The artists featured each week were all different from each other in terms of style and approach. I really enjoyed the variety.
- The courses and videos remain available for users to view after the end date of the six-week program. I didn’t actually finish the kourse so I will definitely be taking advantage of this.
- Danny Gregory (co-founder of Sketchbook Skool) posted little videos of himself doing the weekly homework on his blog every week. I really liked these videos and I would recommend looking them up if you’d like more of a feel for the content before signing up.
- The videos were very short and mostly focused on talking, with very little time in comparison spent on demos. There was one week in particular which was so heavy on talking and biographical information that it generated some user complaints. I did notice that some extra content was posted to this lesson in the following days, however. I was disappointed because I had the impression from promo material that this particular week was to focus on making books, but I had seen all the same content elsewhere (accordion books and mini one-page books). The instructor referred participants to a how-to book on book-binding for more information.
- Every time I logged in on Fridays to view the new lessons, there were a number of participants who had already viewed all of the videos and posted their completed homework. I am on EST and usually logged in around 9 or 10 am on Friday. I realize that people in other time zones could view the content earlier than me, but I thought that the amount of content in each lesson could have been more as it was intended to cover an entire week.
- There were some technical issues which prevented some people from being able to download PDFs from the site. Eventually, this issue was fixed but there were a lot of comments about it in the forums which distracted me from the content. Hopefully, this issue is fixed for future iterations of the kourse.
- Even though most of the homework can be done with materials that you probably already have on hand (pencil, ink, watercolor, etc.), I would have appreciated a materials list before the kourse started. If this was posted, I missed it. I absolutely LOVED Penelope Dullaghan’s week, but there were some materials that she used that I don’t have as a part of my normal supplies such as oil paint, rubber brayer, acetate sheets, linoleum and lino carving tools. I was so inspired after watching her videos, but I didn’t have the stuff on hand so I wasn’t able to jump in and do the assignment like I would have done otherwise.
My completed homework for Felix Scheinberger’s week:
My overall impression of this Sketchbook Skool kourse is that it is ideal for someone who is relatively new to drawing and keeping sketchbooks and who needs/wants a lot of encouragement, inspiration, and interaction with others to stay on track. The inspiration and information I gained from the kourse was very worthwhile for me, but I don’t think it would be worth $99.
I also think this format may not be for me, or that I have some ADD tendencies, because I started to get distracted and lose track and never officially completed all the lessons or all of the homework. The forums seemed a little awkward for me to use so I largely didn’t participate in the discussions. I find the setup of facebook groups more conducive for giving and sharing feedback in general.
Ultimately, it is not necessary AT ALL to take a class on how to keep a sketchbook. When I think back over the years, I realize I have learned the most by just looking at other people’s artwork, and from books. If you like to get video based information, then Sketchbook Skool might be for you. For free, you can look for videos on YouTube and you can also check out Strathmore Free Online Workshops (keeping in mind that they are meant to promote Strathmore products). For less money than Sketchbook Skool, you can also find some art courses on Craftsy (look out for sales) and Creativebug (they offer a free 14 day trial). If you know of any other sources for video based art instruction, please leave me a comment because I’d love to check it out!
I agree with your assessment. I have taken all of the SBS courses and fourn Expressing the weakest. I thought that the klasses would build on each other and the previous ones have but Expressing was an island to itself. I’m hoping this next one will be better in content.
Thanks for your honesty.
Thanks for your input Barbara!
I have thought about this, Should I take another sketchbook class? and my answer to myself was No. However in a moment of weakness I did take the most recent Expressing. But this just confirmed that I should not take anymore SBS classes.
I thought the earlier ones were better (at least for me) and I did get a lot out of them. And I also was introduced to some fantastic teachers some of whom I now follow on their blogs.
Maybe this is a case of maturing. I have now thought carefully about what I want to do with my art and when and how I want to sketch. This has lead me to realize that most of what I have gotten from these last two classes is wasted on me. But maybe it is because I took Seeing and Beginning and then Stretching that I have a better idea about what I want. I certainly know what I do NOT want to do.
Two teachers whose classes I would recommend are Liz Steele and Roz. I thought they both (but especially Roz) pushed me to do a better job of sketching and habit forming although those were more Sketching classes than they were Sketchbook classes. And they were not cheap although worth the cost.
I agree about Crafty. I especially like Marc Holmes Travel Sketching class. And if you are into nature sketching you will really appreciate John Muir Laws’ blog which includes many videos about sketching in nature and “how-tos” about trees, birds, flowers, forests, hills, rocks, etc, etc.
Thanks so much for the John Muir link, Diane. I will definitely check it out as I love nature sketching. I also liked hearing about what you thought of the other SBS programs compared to this one.
I have also taken SBS classes, and while I like them, and admire all of the artists and the time they devoted to building the school, I got more out of my $20 (sale price) Marc Taro Holmes Craftsy course. I have since taken a few other Craftsy courses. Some are excellent, some are disappointing. But they do stand behind a money back guarantee for classes that you don’t like. Overall, I highly recommended Craftsy.
Love your homework assignment! Thinking of grilled cheese right now. Glad you reviewed the course– it’s too bad that we can’t find out more about the content until we pay.
I agree that I wish there was more information available before we had to pay. I think I was so disappointed in the bookmaking week because the video that was released as a teaser was actually the most interesting part about that whole weekly lesson. I was expecting a significant amount of additional information and I felt like it was a big letdown.
I have been searching far and wide for reviews of Sketchbook Skool, honest reviews. So finding comments here was interesting. I have taken all of classes, and am in Polishing, now. This may be my last one. What I find good about SBS is meeting new (to me) artists and teachers. Tommy Kane for example. Being introduced to that world beyond my borders has made SBS valuable to me. However, at this point the sections are getting to be repetitious, or is it just me. But, this class is just starting, so maybe I will be more settled in my opinions at the end. We’ll see.
Thanks for your comment. I am also curious to hear what others think of Polishing once it is complete.
Comments are closed.